The Price of Being Myself
I have discovered an investment strategy with a truly spectacular track record.
It's called Being Authentic.
The returns, in my experience, have been absolutely fucking terrible.
And I keep investing.
This is not going to be one of those inspirational articles where the author bravely reveals that honesty eventually brought him the perfect relationship, a six-figure job, and a golden retriever named Wisdom.
I already have a dog. She is not named Wisdom. The rest of the supposed rewards have been rather less reliable.
I tell people the truth about my life. If things are difficult, I say so. If I'm struggling, I say so. If I disagree, I say so. If I have fucked something up, I try to own it.
It's a wildly inefficient strategy for navigating a world in which everybody wants authenticity right up until it's inconvenient.
Vulnerability, Terms and Conditions Apply
A couple of years ago I was living in Spain when a family crisis exploded. I told the people I was working with what was happening. I explained that I needed to go to Bulgaria briefly, that I would continue working, and that I needed some understanding.
I believed I was speaking with adults.
I had apparently missed Section 47B of the Corporate Family Agreement: We care about your personal life provided it does not become personal.
The professional details belong in another entry, complete with a firing ceremony and a box of shoes. For now, the important part is that I chose openness, and it cost me.
Dating has supplied its own practical demonstrations.
Someone gets to know me, likes the way I dress, likes how I treat her, likes my independence. Then comes the exciting new phase in which the qualities she admired need to be remodeled under new management.
At work they hire your judgment, then ask you to stop exercising it.
In relationships they admire who you are, then start issuing software patches to your personality.
Ben 2.0: Now With Reduced Autonomy!
Installation declined.
Am I a Masochist or Just Terrible at Learning?
This is the question I ask myself.
If I can recognize a pattern so well, why do I keep doing something when I can often anticipate the price?
Do I enjoy the pain?
I don't believe that's what I'm choosing. I'm choosing to behave according to principles I consider worthwhile, even after repeated evidence that those principles are not a reliable method of acquiring comfort.
What a fucking sales pitch.
I could be more guarded. More calculated. I could turn every conversation into a risk assessment and expose exactly the amount of humanity permitted by the current threat model.
As an engineer, I could build an excellent system for that.
The horrifying part is that I'd have to live inside it.
The Backdated Apology Department
I've made plenty of mistakes myself. Some were spectacular. Some hurt people I cared about.
And sometimes, years later, I've contacted someone and said: I was a dickhead. What I did was fucked up. I'm sorry.
Years later.
No PR campaign. No redemption badge. No guarantee the person even wants to hear from me.
I don't say this as proof that I'm a good man. I say it because I want to be able to look at myself without pretending the unpleasant parts of my history didn't happen.
That standard applies when I've been hurt, too. I don't want to manufacture a saint out of myself simply because somebody else behaved badly.
Virtue Has No Cashback Program
Stoicism came along and gave me language for something I'd already been doing: choosing conduct according to an internal standard rather than demanding that the outcome cooperate.
This does not mean that the price is imaginary.
The price has been real. Jobs. Relationships. Trust. Stability. Pain.
I'm not declaring that authenticity secretly makes life wonderful. I'm saying something considerably less marketable.
It has hurt me. A lot. And I'm still choosing it.
Maybe I will learn better boundaries. Maybe I'll become more selective about whom I trust. Maybe this entire operating model needs a security review.
But I don't want the solution to be becoming a fake version of myself.
Which is ridiculous, really. I've spent twenty-five years optimizing systems for efficiency, and the system I refuse to optimize is apparently my own willingness to be human.
Worst ROI in the portfolio.
Still not selling.